Lupin nodded grimly. "The fortress is set on a tiny island way out to sea. But
they don't need walls and water to keep the prisoners in. Not when they're all
trapped inside their own heads, incapable of a single cheerful thought. Most of
them go mad within weeks."
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban - Full Review
by JK Rowling
The third book in the Harry Potter series is read once again by Stephen Fry who puts
in his usual excellent performance, reading the first of the Potter books to feature
truly dark themes.
This is a gripping novel which holds the reader's attention from start to finish with
a constant air of lurking threat and impending confrontation.
This novel makes good use of the magical inventions - inventions that Rowling is so
good at dreaming up - to create a plot which is strongly dependent on magical tools
and techniques in its resolution, but which is nonetheless remarkably easy to follow
once these magical ideas are understood. Reader's are introduced to the Marauder's
Map, the Knight Bus and the Dementor's Kiss, and other such magical ideas without
which the Potter series would be incomplete.
Unusually in Azkaban, it is Rowling's characters who are not entirely convincing -
particularly the terrifying Sirius Black and the even more daunting Dementors. These
archetypal beings give the impression of being less well thought through than the
more human, and more mundane new characters who first make their appearance in
Prisoner of Azkaban.
Professor Lupin - reticent, enigmatic, and with an air about him of a wounded, but
determined hound - is altogether more accessible. But he is in some ways quite as
formidable as Black. The bespectacled Professor Trelawney is another interesting new
character. A curious mixture of the insecure and the outrageous, she doesn't really
fit in at Hogwarts, but nonetheless she seems to have some sort of role to play in
the overall scheme of things. It is not immediately apparent when reading Prisoner of
Azkaban, but Trelawney's storyline is quite as fascinating as the other aspects of
the novel.
The problem with the Dementors and Black is hard to pin down, but there isn't quite
the same powerful underlying logic to these creations as to the other characters in
the series. It is a curious thing about Rowling's character's that the darker the
forces propelling their actions, the less convincing the character.
Of the three main characters - Potter himself, Ron and Hermione - it is with the last
that problems of characterization begin to creep in at this stage in the series. With
Hermione, it is as though Rowling attempts to create a sort of supergirl with
flaws.
The result is Hermione works very well in moving the story forward. but alas, too
frequently, Hermione is aware of details in the story that only she and the author
seem to know. Too frequently she appears more of a narrative device than a real
character. Her actions seem to derive from a need for something to be said or done or
experienced for the sake of the plot, rather than from the motivation of a consistent
character with a consistent personality. This is again a disappointment given
Rowling's very real talent in creating characters.
Prisoner of Azkaban raises in the mind of the reader some questions about how the
wizarding world goes about policing itself and dispensing justice. This theme is
clearly not incidental to the storyline. The question was hinted at - perhaps more
than merely hinted at - in Chamber of Secrets and the theme is further developed
here.
Looking more deeply at the story there clearly are other themes waiting to be
discovered, not least in the actions and attitudes of the story's most accessible
characters as they try to engage with their not always ideal situations.
Bloomsbury Publishing
Unabridged Audio CD Edition – 2006
Read by Stephen Fry
